Keeping your home secure is a top priority, but deciding whether to change your locks or rekey them can be confusing. Many homeowners wonder which option is best, especially during a home security upgrade or after moving into a new place. At Old Glory Locksmith, we’re often asked this exact question.
In this guide, we’ll break down the common scenarios where lock rekeying services are ideal, and when it’s better to go for a full lock change. Let’s explore the differences, benefits, and practical advice to keep your home safe and secure.
What’s the Difference Between Lock Rekeying and Lock Replacement?
Before you decide what’s right for your situation, it’s important to understand the key differences.
- Lock Rekeying involves changing the internal pins inside your existing locks so old keys no longer work. A new key will be provided.
- Lock Replacement means removing the entire lock and installing a brand-new one.
Each option serves a different purpose depending on your situation, budget, and security needs.
When to Rekey Your Locks
Rekeying is a fast, cost-effective method to enhance your home’s security without changing the hardware.
1. You’ve Moved into a New Home
If you’ve just bought a house, it’s crucial to rekey the locks. Previous owners, realtors, or contractors might still have copies of the key.
- Ensure your home is exclusively accessible to you
- Affordable security reset without full replacement
2. Lost Your Keys
Losing your keys poses a major security risk. Rekeying ensures that anyone who finds or has your old key can no longer access your home.
- Quick and inexpensive
- Peace of mind after a key is lost or stolen
3. You Want One Key for All Locks
Tired of juggling multiple keys? Rekeying can match all locks to one master key, provided the locks are the same brand or compatible.
- Simplifies access
- Great for homeowners and landlords
4. After a Breakup or Roommate Moves Out
If a roommate, tenant, or ex-partner leaves and you’re unsure about key copies, rekeying is the smart and secure step.
When to Replace Your Locks
There are cases where lock replacement vs rekey favors full replacement due to damage, age, or the need for a more advanced system.
1. Your Locks Are Worn Out or Damaged
If your lock is rusted, jammed, or consistently sticking, a replacement is necessary.
- Enhances ease of use and safety
- Prevents lockouts or failures
2. You Want a Home Security Upgrade
Planning a home security upgrade? Installing high-security locks or smart locks is a wise move for modern protection.
- Supports digital integration (smart locks)
- Anti-pick and bump-proof technologies
3. You Want a New Style or Finish
Changing your doors, hardware, or design? Upgrading locks for aesthetic or functional consistency may require full replacement.
- Complements new décor
- Gives your home a refreshed, uniform look
Benefits of Choosing Professional Locksmiths
Choosing to work with professional locksmiths like Old Glory Locksmith ensures the job is done right the first time. We offer:
- Honest security assessments
- Fast, affordable residential rekeying
- Skilled lock replacement services
- Fully licensed and insured locksmiths
Whether it’s a single door or a whole-home key, we’ve got you covered with high-quality service and peace of mind.
Quick Decision Guide: Rekey or Replace?
Here’s a handy checklist to help decide:
| Situation | Rekey | Replace |
| Moved into a new home | ✅ | |
| Lost keys | ✅ | |
| Want a single master key | ✅ | |
| Locks are damaged or old | ✅ | |
| Home security system upgrade | ✅ | |
| Changing door style or hardware | ✅ |
FAQs
Q: Is rekeying safe enough after a break-in?
A: If the locks were not damaged, rekeying is often sufficient. However, if the intruder tampered with the hardware, replacement is recommended.
Q: How long does it take to rekey a lock?
A: A professional can usually rekey a standard lock in about 15–30 minutes.
Q: Can I rekey my locks myself?
A: While DIY kits are available, professional rekeying ensures accuracy and security, especially for complex locks.
Q: How much does it cost to rekey vs replace a lock?
A: Rekeying is generally more affordable. Replacement costs vary based on lock type and brand.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re considering rekeying after a move or replacing old locks during a home upgrade, both options are valid depending on your needs. The key is knowing when to use each.
At Old Glory Locksmith, we specialize in personalized lock rekeying services, expert lock repair, and full lock replacement. Serving homeowners across the area, we bring security, experience, and professionalism right to your doorstep.
Ready to Secure Your Home the Right Way?
Contact Old Glory Locksmith today for expert guidance on lock rekeying or replacement. Fast, affordable, and always reliable.
